Congressman John Boener has submitted a House Republican health-care plan that, he says, would cut deficits by $68 billion over the next 10 years by limiting lawsuits, simplifying paperwork and encouraging small businesses to pool insurance risks.
The plan's $61 billion price tag is about 6 percent of the Democrats' $1 trillion cost. If it's workable, it's an example of thinking hard to do good things cheaper.
The Congressional Budget Office has evaluated the Boener plan and makes these observations:
* Tort reform -- lawsuit limits -- would save $41 billion over 10 years.
* Administrative simplification would save $6 billion over 10 years.
* A state innovations program would cost $32 billion over 10 years.
* Reinsurance and high-risk pools would cost $24 billion over 10 years.
First, do no harm. Though overall it cuts costs, the plan does not seem to vastly increase the percent of Americans with health insurance. Perhaps 3 million more needy Americans would have insurance. Democrats say their plan would cover 30 million more.
For the Republicans, cutting costs seems to be a first step. Covering a larger portion of the nation seems a secondary priority. In a deep and shaky recession, with only tentative signs of recovery, this makes some sense.
The Democrats ought to take a close look at this.
Frank Warner
Recent Comments