I concede there is no credible evidence that President Obama was not born in Hawaii.
But I do wonder why, when people like Terry Gross of NPR, Helene Cooper of The New York Times or Lisa Lerer of Politico “report” on the low-burner, slightly whacky controversy, they simply assume an Aug. 4, 1961, Hawaii birth certificate exists and everyone has seen it.
Obama’s original birth certificate may exist, but the public certainly has not seen it. Last year, Democrat Philip Berg of Pennsylvania sued to see the document, but the courts refused to order its public disclosure. According to Berg, Obama’s grandmother said he was born in Kenya. Berg probably is wrong about that, but if Obama was born outside the United States, he would have been ineligible for the U.S. presidency (in fact, still ineligible).
(By the way, questions also were raised last year about John McCain’s eligibility to be president. He was born in Panama at a time when, according to several credible authorities, a Panama birth even to U.S. military parents didn’t automatically make the baby an American “natural-born citizen.”)
Mystifying secrecy. So far, we’ve seen only computer-generated 2007 versions of Obama’s “certification of live birth.” It’s not that this 2007 document isn’t official, but the original certificate is more likely to have evidence of exactly what doctors and officials wrote or typed back in 1961. The original is likely to have more information, such as the name of a hospital.
The conspiracy theorists grow increasingly more suspicious as the original certificate remains hidden and news agencies show zero curiosity about it. News “reports” on the matter only beg the question and assume we “know” Obama is a natural-born American.
I’m not a “birther,” but I don’t understand the secrecy. Let’s see the original birth certificate. It shouldn’t be hard to produce.
Frank Warner
* * *
Update: CNN's Lou Dobbs on July 23 reported the original 1961 birth certificate was destroyed, but Dobbs cited no source for his story. Others already are saying Dobbs is wrong. Dr. Chiyome Fukino, director of the Hawaii Department of Health, last year declared he had "seen the original vital records" and could verify Obama is a natural-born citizen. Fukino better have seen the original birth certificate, or he just gave birth to more "birthers."
Note: Snopes and Factcheck.org ignored the real controversy and decided to attack a few idiots who said the 2007 birth certificate was "forged." That certificate wasn't forged. Hawaiian officials issued it. But the question is not whether the 2007 document was forged. The question is, has the public been allowed to see the original 1961 document, the paper certificate filed in 1961? The answer is, no. Meanwhile, Factcheck.org calls the 2007 document the original. Wrong. Check your facts! Let's see the original paper filed in 1961.
See also: Reward: $5 for proof President Obama’s 1961 Hawaii birth certificate is public.
Recent Comments